Fool-proof UID? I am concerned.
The other day Sri Nilekani assured the press that UID will be fool-proof while signing an MOU with AP government agencies for getting the work done on a pilot project basis.
The proven performance of government in issuing iris based ration cards, simple photograph based voter cards gives reasons for serious concern and the confidence of Sri Nilakani may be unwarranted. Million plus bogus ration cards cry out.
Even a genuine person with UID will get into identity crisis because multiple agencies are involved the way Nilekani is signing MOU s and it will be a nightmarish situation with poor accountabily and complex paper trail and practically absent audit trail, compromising data integrity quite seriously.
Finally undesired elements will manage the cover of UID properly to further complicate the situation because of poor loosely administered process involving multiple disparate contract based data collection and entry.
Ultimately UID may become more an abused process to authenticate illegal immigrants and terrorists.
I wish we had a single point responsibility and single point one time authenticated data entry with encrypted wide area communication based network in position.
Verification and validation processes at the time of issue and post issue stages, and while in use, pose stupendous challenges.
Further UID is not needed by any one for ration or for tax or for any other purpose and so why any one is under pressure to get one?
Lack of UID cannot be made an offence. It is a catch22 situation. I can only empathise with Nilekani.
It looks like a doomed project and wonder who will be the scape goat.
What no IAS man wanted, has been palmed off to him.
Nilekani is innocent in our government's ways of working.
Comments